Makita vs CRAFTSMAN Table Saws: Which Brand Fits You?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The makita vs CRAFTSMAN table saw search often leads to confusion because these brands make different tool types. This comparison looks at a Makita jig saw and a CRAFTSMAN circular saw. Both are handheld power tools designed for cutting materials. The main difference lies in their power source and cutting mechanism. One uses a corded electric motor for precise jigsaw cuts, while the other is a battery-powered circular saw. Understanding these specs helps you pick the right tool for your project.
Key differences
| Aspect | Makita 6.5-Amp Top Handle Corded Jig Saw | CRAFTSMAN V20 4-1/2-Inch Cordless Circular Saw |
|---|---|---|
| Power Source | Corded | Cordless |
| Voltage | 120V | 20V MAX |
| Motor Type | 6.5 Amp | Brushless |
| Blade Diameter | not listed | 4-1/2 Inch |
| Weight | 5.3 lbs | 6.81 pounds |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Makita 6.5-Amp Top Handle Corded Jig Saw if
- You need continuous power for detailed cutting tasks without worrying about battery life.
- You prefer a lighter tool that reduces operator fatigue during extended use.
- You require a tool with a through-the-body dust port for efficient vacuum connection.
Choose CRAFTSMAN V20 4-1/2-Inch Cordless Circular Saw if
- You want the flexibility to work in areas without electrical outlets.
- You need a faster no-load speed for cutting dimensional lumber quickly.
- You value an electronic blade brake for enhanced safety during operation.
Verdict: Choose the Makita if you prioritize precision, lightweight handling, and corded reliability for detailed work. Select the CRAFTSMAN if you need portability, higher cutting speed, and the safety features of a cordless circular saw. Your choice depends on whether you value detailed control or versatile, battery-powered power.
Makita vs Craftsman Key Specs
power source
The Makita 6.5-Amp Top Handle Corded Jig Saw relies on a constant 120V corded connection. This ensures steady power without worrying about battery levels during long projects. In contrast, the CRAFTSMAN V20 4-1/2-Inch Cordless Circular Saw uses a 20V MAX battery system. This offers mobility and freedom from cords, making it ideal for job sites without nearby outlets. You must choose between the consistent output of the Makita corded design or the portability of the CRAFTSMAN cordless setup. Each approach suits different work environments.
amperage
The Makita tool features a 6.5 Amp motor, providing robust power for cutting various materials. This amperage rating indicates a strong drive for consistent performance in a jig saw application. The CRAFTSMAN circular saw does not list an amperage rating in the provided data. Instead, it highlights a brushless motor with up to 4500 no-load rpm. While the Makita offers a clear amperage figure for power assessment, the CRAFTSMAN relies on speed and battery voltage metrics. You get specific electrical data from Makita, while CRAFTSMAN focuses on rotational speed.
no-load speed
The CRAFTSMAN V20 circular saw operates at up to 4500 no-load rpm. This high speed is designed for efficient cutting in dimensional lumber and other materials. The Makita jig saw offers a variable speed control dial ranging from 500 to 3,100 SPM. This allows you to match the speed to the specific application, offering precision over raw speed. The CRAFTSMAN provides a higher maximum cutting speed, while the Makita provides a wider adjustable range for delicate or detailed work. You choose between high-speed efficiency and adjustable precision.
blade diameter
The CRAFTSMAN circular saw uses a 4-1/2 inch blade diameter. This size is standard for compact circular saws, allowing for deep cuts in standard lumber. The Makita jig saw data does not specify a blade diameter, as jig saw blades vary in length and type. The CRAFTSMAN offers a clear, fixed blade size that defines its cutting capacity. The Makita requires you to select compatible jig saw blades separately. For a defined cutting width and depth, the CRAFTSMAN provides explicit specifications, while the Makita focuses on the tool body.
weight
The Makita jig saw weighs only 5.3 lbs, contributing to reduced operator fatigue during extended use. Its well-balanced design further aids handling in compact areas. The CRAFTSMAN circular saw weighs 6.81 pounds. This slightly heavier weight may affect maneuverability for some users, though it can provide stability. The Makita offers a lighter profile for easier handling, especially in overhead or tight spaces. You benefit from the Makita's lighter construction if reducing fatigue is a priority.
Which tool matches your cutting needs?
You need steady power for detailed work
The Makita jig saw offers a 6.5-amp motor with variable speed control from 500 to 3,100 SPM. This allows you to match the speed to your material. The corded 120V connection ensures consistent power. The low-profile design and 5.3-pound weight reduce fatigue during intricate cuts in tight spaces.
You want cordless freedom and speed
The CRAFTSMAN circular saw features a brushless motor reaching 4,500 rpm. Its cordless V20 design provides mobility without a power cord. The electronic blade brake stops the blade quickly for safety. The auxiliary handle and on-board blade key storage add convenience for quick changes and comfortable handling on the job site.
You prioritize accuracy and dust management
The Makita tool includes a through-the-body dust port for efficient vacuum connection. Its counterbalance system reduces vibration for smoother operation. The tool-less blade change system speeds up setup. The die-cast aluminum housing base adds durability. These specs help you maintain precision and keep your workspace cleaner during various cutting tasks.
The products compared
Makita 6.5-Amp Top Handle Corded Jig Saw
Best for: Detailed cuts in tight spaces
- Amperage
- 6.5 Amp
- Voltage
- 120V
- Power Source
- Corded
- Dimensions
- 9.25 × 3.86 × 7.8 inches
View on Amazon: Makita 6.5-Amp Top Handle Corded Jig Saw Affiliate link
This Makita jig saw features a 6.5-amp motor and variable speed control from 500 to 3,100 SPM. The top handle design and low profile allow for better maneuverability in tight spaces. Weighing just 5.3 lbs, it reduces operator fatigue during extended use. The through-the-body dust port helps manage debris. It suits users needing precise cuts in various materials.
Pros
- 6.5 Amp motor delivers fast cutting performance
- Variable speed dial adjusts from 500 to 3,100 SPM
- Tool-less blade change system speeds up swaps
- Counterbalance system reduces vibration for smoother cuts
Cons
- Corded power limits mobility compared to battery tools
- Top handle design may not suit all user preferences
- No mention of included blade set in specifications
Good fit if
- You need precise cuts in tight spaces
- You prefer a lightweight tool for reduced fatigue
- You want variable speed control for different materials
Skip if
- You require a cordless tool for remote work
- You prefer a side-handle design for stability
- You need a tool with a built-in light
Verdict: Makita 6.5A Top Handle Jig Saw is ideal for users who prioritize maneuverability and speed in confined areas. Its lightweight build and variable speed settings make it a strong choice for detailed woodworking tasks.
CRAFTSMAN V20 4-1/2-Inch Cordless Circular Saw
Best for: Light-duty portable cutting tasks
- Blade Diameter
- 4-1/2 Inch
- No-Load Speed
- 4500 rpm
- Power Source
- Cordless
- Voltage
- 20V MAX
- Dimensions
- 18.5 × 5.51 × 6.73 inches
- Weight
- 6.81 pounds
View on Amazon: CRAFTSMAN V20 4-1/2-Inch Cordless Circular Saw Affiliate link
The CRAFTSMAN V20 circular saw features a brushless motor delivering up to 4500 no-load rpm. It uses a 4-1/2 inch blade and operates on a 20V MAX power source. The tool includes an auxiliary handle, a front dust port, and an electronic blade brake. It weighs 6.81 pounds and measures 18.5 inches in length. This compact design suits users needing portable cutting power for dimensional lumber.
Pros
- Brushless motor reaches 4500 rpm
- Electronic blade brake for safety
- On-board front dust port
- Sliding rip fence for accuracy
Cons
- 4-1/2 inch blade limits cutting depth
- Bare tool requires separate battery
- No onboard storage for spare blades
Good fit if
- You need a lightweight, cordless saw for quick cuts
- You value an electronic brake for safety
- You work with 1x dimensional lumber
Skip if
- You require a corded power source
- You need to cut thick stock beyond 4-1/2 inch capacity
- You want a complete kit with battery and charger
Verdict: CRAFTSMAN V20 4-1/2 in Cordless Circular Saw is a solid choice for DIYers who prioritize portability and safety features like the electronic brake. It fits users who already own V20 batteries and need a compact tool for light-duty framing or trim work.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Makita 6.5-Amp Top Handle Corded Jig Saw | CRAFTSMAN V20 4-1/2-Inch Cordless Circular Saw |
|---|---|---|
| Blade Diameter | not stated | 4-1/2 Inch |
| Amperage | 6.5 Amp | not stated |
| No-Load Speed | not stated | 4500 rpm |
| Voltage | 120V | not stated |
| Power Source | Corded | Cordless |
| Dimensions | 9.25 × 3.86 × 7.8 inches | 18.5 × 5.51 × 6.73 inches |
| Weight | not stated | 6.81 pounds |
| Color | White | Black, Red |
| Model | JV0600K-R | CMCS405B |
Frequently asked questions
Can I use a Makita jig saw for ripping lumber like a table saw?
No. The Makita tool listed is a jig saw designed for detailed cuts in tight spaces. It is not built for long, straight rips. Table saws have flat tables and fences to guide large sheets. This handheld tool is for curves and intricate work, not structural ripping tasks.
Is the CRAFTSMAN circular saw a good replacement for a stationary table saw?
It depends on your space. The CRAFTSMAN V20 is a portable, cordless tool. It lacks the stability and precision of a fixed table saw. It suits light-duty framing or trim work where you need mobility. For accurate crosscuts or rip cuts on wide boards, a table saw remains the better choice.
Do I need a table saw if I already have a Makita jig saw?
You likely do, for different tasks. The Makita jig saw excels at cutting curves and detailed shapes. It cannot replace the flat surface and fence system of a table saw. You need a table saw for straight, repetitive cuts and handling large sheet goods efficiently. They serve complementary roles in a workshop.
Which brand offers better portability for job site cutting?
CRAFTSMAN offers better portability with its V20 cordless model. The circular saw weighs 6.81 pounds and runs on batteries. You do not need a power outlet. The Makita jig saw is corded and plugs into 120V power. While lighter, it requires a cord and outlet, limiting free movement on a busy job site.
Can I cut metal with these tools like I would on a table saw?
Not safely or effectively. Neither tool is designed for metal cutting like a table saw with a metal blade. The Makita jig saw handles wood and plastic. The CRAFTSMAN circular saw cuts wood and composite materials. Using them on metal can damage the blades and create dangerous sparks. Use a dedicated metal-cutting saw.
How does the weight of these tools compare to a table saw?
They are significantly lighter. The CRAFTSMAN circular saw weighs 6.81 pounds. The Makita jig saw is even smaller, measuring 9.25 inches in length. A standard table saw weighs over 100 pounds. These handheld tools offer easy transport but lack the massive mass and vibration damping of a stationary table saw.