RYOBI One+ P5231 18V Lithium Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared

Comparing alternatives to the RYOBI P5231

RYOBI ONE+ HP 18V 7-1/4-Inch Brushless Circular Saw

The RYOBI ONE+ HP 18V Circular Saw targets a different cutting task entirely. It features a 7-1/4-inch blade and reaches 5,000 RPM for fast, straight cuts. This tool includes an integrated LED light for precision work. It weighs 9.63 pounds and measures 13.9 inches in length. Unlike the P5231 jigsaw, this circular saw does not offer orbital settings or variable speed control for curves. It is ideal for framers and carpenters who need high-speed cutting capacity. You should pick this if you require accurate bevel settings and speed over intricate shaping capabilities. It shares the 18V platform but serves a distinct role in your tool collection.

Makita 18V Brushless Cordless Jig Saw

The Makita 18V Brushless Jig Saw offers high speed and orbital control for users with existing 18V LXT batteries. It prioritizes cutting efficiency and accuracy over portability. The tool measures 17.7 inches in length and 14.4 inches in height, making it larger than the RYOBI P5231. It lacks the specific blade-saving base feature found on the P5231. This Makita model is suited for users who value consistent performance in demanding applications. You should choose this if you need robust orbital settings and do not mind the increased size. It provides a similar cordless experience but focuses on power and precision rather than the compact design of the RYOBI option.

RYOBI ONE+ HP Cordless Brushless Jig Saw

The RYOBI ONE+ HP Brushless Jig Saw is a precise, lightweight option for users who prioritize portability. It weighs only 4.6 pounds and measures 12 inches in length, making it easier to handle than the P5231. This model features variable speed control for detailed work. It shares the 18V platform and green and black color scheme. Unlike the P5231, it does not mention a built-in dust blower or blade-saving base in the provided data. It is ideal for cutting in tight spaces. You should pick this if you need a lighter tool with variable speed adjustments. It offers similar orbital capabilities but with a focus on maneuverability and brushless efficiency.

RIDGID 7-1/4 in. Cordless Brushless Circular Saw

The RIDGID 18V Brushless Circular Saw delivers standard cutting capacity with efficient brushless performance. It is designed for RIDGID ecosystem users who value platform consistency. The tool measures 10 inches in width and 10 inches in height. It does not offer the orbital settings or fine control of the P5231 jigsaw. This circular saw is better for straight cuts and general construction tasks. You should choose this if you already use RIDGID 18V batteries and need reliable power for larger materials. It lacks the compact size and specialized features of the RYOBI jigsaw. It serves a different purpose in your workshop, focusing on durability and consistent performance for heavy-duty cutting.

AUTOJARE 18V Brushless Cordless Bandsaw

The AUTOJARE 18V Brushless Cordless Bandsaw suits users who need a compact, multi-material tool with variable speeds. It measures 13.4 inches in length and 5.12 inches in height. This bandsaw is practical for those who already have compatible batteries and do not require deep cutting capacity. Unlike the P5231, it uses a band blade rather than a reciprocating blade. It is ideal for portable multi-material cutting tasks. You should pick this if you need versatility in cutting different materials with variable speed control. It offers a different cutting mechanism and compact form factor. It shares the 18V cordless platform but provides a unique solution for intricate or curved cuts in various materials.

Makita 18V Brushless Cordless Jig Saw

The Makita 18V Brushless Jig Saw offers precise control and efficient cutting for users with existing Makita batteries. It is ideal for detailed work where variable speed and orbital settings matter. The tool features a turquoise color and model number XVJ04Z-R. It does not mention a dust blower or blade-saving base in the provided data. This Makita model is suited for users who prioritize accuracy and control. You should choose this if you need detailed cutting capabilities with existing Makita 18V batteries. It provides a similar cordless experience but focuses on precision and brushless efficiency. It differs from the P5231 in its specific orbital control features and overall design philosophy.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

RYOBI 18V Cordless Orbital Jigsaw

Best for: Users with existing 18V batteries needing orbital control

Voltage

18V

Power Source

Cordless

Dimensions

12 × 11 × 6.5 inches

Weight

1.12 ounces

View on Amazon: RYOBI 18V Cordless Orbital Jigsaw Affiliate link

The RYOBI One+ P5231 is an 18V cordless jigsaw designed for precision cutting. It features four orbital settings to adjust cut speed and finish, making it suitable for both straight lumber cuts and curved shapes. A built-in dust blower clears debris for better visibility, while LED lighting aids work in low-light conditions. The tool includes a blade-saving base and a trigger lock system for extended control. It requires a separate 18V battery.

Pros

• Four orbital settings for versatile cutting applications
• Built-in dust blower clears debris from the cut line
• LED lighting improves visibility in dim areas
• Blade-saving base extends accessory life
• Trigger lock system reduces hand fatigue

Cons

• Battery not included with the tool
• Lightweight design at 1.12 ounces may feel less substantial
• No mention of a variable speed trigger in specifications

Good fit if

• You need orbital settings for different material types
• You work in areas with limited lighting
• You already own RYOBI 18V batteries

Skip if

• You require a complete kit with battery and charger
• You prefer a heavier tool for stability
• You need a variable speed trigger

Verdict: RYOBI P5231 18V Cordless Jigsaw is a capable tool for users who already have 18V batteries and need adjustable orbital cutting. It suits those who value clear visibility through dust blowing and LED lighting. It is not ideal for buyers seeking a ready-to-use kit.

2 Also great

RYOBI ONE+ HP 18V 7-1/4-Inch Brushless Circular Saw

Best for: Existing RYOBI users needing speed and precision

Blade Diameter

7-1/4 in.

No-Load Speed

5,000 RPM

Voltage

18V

Power Source

Cordless

Dimensions

13.9 × 9.06 × 7.95 inches

Weight

6.5 pounds

View on Amazon: RYOBI ONE+ HP 18V 7-1/4-Inch Brushless Circular Saw Affiliate link

This tool-only circular saw uses an 18V brushless motor to reach 5,000 RPM for faster cuts. It handles 7-1/4-inch blades with a maximum depth of 2-9/16 inches at zero degrees. You get six bevel detents for angle adjustments and a built-in LED light. It weighs 9.63 pounds and fits into the RYOBI ONE+ battery system for compatible power.

Pros

• Brushless motor delivers 5,000 RPM for 3X faster cutting
• Six bevel detents at 0, 15, 22-1/2, 30, 45, and 56 degrees
• Maximum cutting depth of 2-9/16 inches at 0 degrees
• Built-in LED worklight improves visibility during cuts

Cons

• Sold as a tool only, requiring a separate battery and charger
• Heavier at 9.63 pounds compared to lighter compact models
• Limited to 18V battery platform compatibility

Good fit if

• You already own RYOBI ONE+ batteries and want to save money
• You need precise bevel angles for framing or trim work
• You prefer a brushless motor for longer runtime and durability

Skip if

• You do not own compatible 18V batteries and need a complete kit
• You require a corded saw for unlimited runtime on large jobs
• You need a compact 5-1/2-inch blade for tight spaces

Verdict: RYOBI ONE+ HP 18V 7-1/4 in Circular Saw is a strong option for existing RYOBI users who need high speed and accurate bevel settings. It suits framers and carpenters who value the 5,000 RPM output and integrated LED light for precision tasks.

3 Also great

Makita 18V Brushless Cordless Jig Saw

Best for: Users with existing 18V LXT batteries

Voltage

18V

Power Source

Cordless

Dimensions

17.7 × 5.31 × 14.4 inches

View on Amazon: Makita 18V Brushless Cordless Jig Saw Affiliate link

This Makita jig saw features an 18V brushless motor delivering 0-3,000 strokes per minute. It includes three orbital settings and straight cutting modes for various materials. The tool has a soft no-load start for accuracy and an LED light. It measures 17.7 inches long and 5.31 inches wide. You get precise control with a large two-finger trigger and lock-on button.

Pros

• Brushless motor reaches 3,000 SPM
• Three orbital settings plus straight cut
• Soft no-load starting mode
• Built-in LED work light

Cons

• Tool only; no battery included
• Larger footprint at 17.7 inches long
• No variable speed dial visible

Good fit if

• You need high speed for fast cuts
• You want orbital settings for rough work
• You already own 18V LXT batteries

Skip if

• You need a complete kit with battery
• You prefer a compact one-handed tool
• You require variable speed dial control

Verdict: Makita 18V Brushless Jig Saw offers high speed and orbital control for users with existing 18V LXT batteries. It suits those who prioritize cutting efficiency and accuracy over portability.

4 Also great

RYOBI ONE+ HP Cordless Brushless Jig Saw

Best for: Precision cutting in tight spaces

Voltage

18 V

Power Source

Cordless

Dimensions

12 × 7.5 × 4 inches

Weight

4.6 pounds

View on Amazon: RYOBI ONE+ HP Cordless Brushless Jig Saw Affiliate link

This RYOBI ONE+ HP jig saw features a brushless motor and variable speed settings ranging from 900 to 3,200 strokes per minute. It includes a 1-inch stroke length and an auto mode for material sensing. The tool weighs 4.6 pounds and measures 12 inches in length. It offers long battery life, cutting up to 120 feet of 1/2-inch plywood on a single charge. It suits users needing precision and control in a compact form factor.

Pros

• Brushless motor delivers 900-3,200 strokes per minute
• Variable speed dial with 6 settings plus auto mode
• Compact design weighs only 4.6 pounds
• 1-inch stroke length for efficient cutting
• Cuts up to 120 feet of 1/2-inch plywood per charge

Cons

• Tool only; battery and charger not included
• Single 1-inch stroke length limits aggressive cutting options
• No dedicated blade clamp key mentioned in specifications

Good fit if

• You need a lightweight tool for detailed work
• You already own RYOBI ONE+ HP batteries
• You want variable speed control for different materials

Skip if

• You require a corded power source for continuous use
• You need a larger stroke length for thick stock
• You want a complete kit with battery and charger included

Verdict: RYOBI ONE+ HP 18V Brushless Jig Saw is a precise, lightweight option for users who prioritize portability and variable speed control in their RYOBI ecosystem.

5

RIDGID 7-1/4 in. Cordless Brushless Circular Saw

Best for: RIDGID 18V battery users

Blade Diameter

7-1/4''

Voltage

18V

Power Source

Cordless

Dimensions

8 × 10 × 10 inches

View on Amazon: RIDGID 7-1/4 in. Cordless Brushless Circular Saw Affiliate link

This RIDGID circular saw is an 18V cordless tool with a 7-1/4 inch blade. It features a brushless motor for efficient power delivery. The unit measures 10 by 10 by 8 inches. It is designed for users who need a reliable 18V platform tool. This saw fits well if you already own RIDGID batteries. It offers a standard blade size for common cuts.

Pros

• 18V battery platform compatibility
• 7-1/4 inch blade diameter
• Brushless motor technology
• Cordless design for mobility

Cons

• Renewed condition may vary
• Tool only, no battery included
• Larger footprint at 10x10x8 inches

Good fit if

• You use the 18V RIDGID battery system
• You need a standard 7-1/4 inch blade
• You prefer cordless tool flexibility

Skip if

• You require a new, factory-sealed unit
• You need a complete kit with battery
• You prefer a compact tool under 8 inches

Verdict: RIDGID 18V Brushless Circular Saw is a solid option for RIDGID ecosystem users. It delivers standard cutting capacity with efficient brushless performance. Choose this if you value platform consistency and reliable power.

6 Best budget

AUTOJARE 18V Brushless Cordless Bandsaw

Best for: portable multi-material cutting tasks

Voltage

18V

Power Source

Cordless

Dimensions

13.4 × 6.69 × 5.12 inches

View on Amazon: AUTOJARE 18V Brushless Cordless Bandsaw Affiliate link

The AUTOJARE DJ-MWQ is an 18V cordless bandsaw designed for cutting metal, plastic, and wood. It features a 400W brushless motor and seven variable speeds for precise control. The tool-free blade change and built-in LED light improve workflow efficiency. It fits users who need a portable solution for varied materials without a fixed station.

Pros

• 400W brushless motor for stable output
• Seven variable speed settings
• Tool-free blade change mechanism
• Built-in LED work light

Cons

• Smaller 2-1/5 inch cutting capacity
• Batteries are not included
• Limited to 18V power source

Good fit if

• You need a portable saw for metal or plastic
• You want variable speed control for different materials
• You already own compatible 18V batteries

Skip if

• You require a large cutting capacity
• You need a dedicated wood-only bandsaw
• You do not have compatible batteries

Verdict: AUTOJARE 18V Brushless Cordless Bandsaw suits users who need a compact, multi-material tool with variable speeds. It is a practical option for those who already have compatible batteries and do not require deep cutting capacity.

7 Best premium

Makita 18V Brushless Cordless Jig Saw

Best for: Detailed cutting with existing Makita batteries

Voltage

18V

Power Source

Cordless

View on Amazon: Makita 18V Brushless Cordless Jig Saw Affiliate link

This Makita jig saw uses an 18V LXT battery and a brushless motor. It offers variable speed from 0 to 3,000 strokes per minute. Three orbital settings help you cut different materials efficiently. The tool includes a soft start, electric brake, and built-in LED light. It is tool-only, so you need a compatible battery. It suits users who need precise, adjustable cutting power.

Pros

• Brushless motor delivers 0-3000 SPM
• Three orbital settings for material versatility
• Soft start ensures accurate starting cuts
• Built-in LED illuminates the work area

Cons

• Tool only, battery not included
• No dust collection port mentioned
• Renewed condition, not new

Good fit if

• You already own Makita 18V batteries
• You need variable speed control for fine cuts
• You prefer brushless motor efficiency

Skip if

• You want a complete kit with battery and charger
• You require a new, factory-sealed unit
• You need a corded saw for unlimited runtime

Verdict: Makita 18V Brushless Jig Saw offers precise control and efficient cutting for users with existing Makita batteries. It is ideal for detailed work where variable speed and orbital settings matter.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions

See also

• ryobi one 18v cordless stick alternatives
• ryobi 1 alternatives